Blog
“Not for Human Consumption” Raw Chocolate Milk Controversy | Episode 168
In this episode of Don’t Eat Poop!, our hosts Matt and Francine dive headfirst into one of the strangest raw milk controversies they’ve seen yet: a Florida dairy selling expensive raw chocolate milk labeled as livestock feed while clearly marketing it to humans.
The hosts unpack the food safety, legal liability, and public health implications behind the “pet food loophole” that many raw milk sellers appear to use. The conversation covers everything from Listeria and E. coli risks in raw dairy to whether warning labels actually protect companies from lawsuits.
Along the way, Matt and Francine ask the question nobody expected to ask in 2026: Who exactly is buying $15 chocolate milk for livestock?
In this episode:
💩 [01:27] TikTok creator discovers her raw chocolate milk is “Not for Human Consumption”
💩 [07:10] Who is buying raw chocolate milk for their livestock?
💩 [09:03] Breaking down Florida statutes surrounding raw milk sales and labeling requirements
💩 [11:34] Does a warning label actually protect companies from food safety lawsuits?
💩 [16:01] Raw milk disclaimers vs restaurant undercooked food warnings
💩 [18:36] The reality of contamination risks in even “clean” dairy operations
💩 [21:56] Why “raw milk is inherently safe” claims frustrate food safety professionals
Disclaimer: Episode title and content do not constitute legal or health advice.
Resources from this episode
Take a look at the TikTok we’re talking about in this episode from creator Emmy Makela: https://www.tiktok.com/@emsthegirl/video/7629027231888575774?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc&web_id=7608973359876458015
Noteworthy quotes from this episode
“Anybody who has livestock knows that they are not providing their livestock with $14.99 half a gallon milk jugs that also have chocolate in them.” – Matt Regusci
“I wonder how many people are buying products that say not for human consumption and don’t even realize it.” – Francine L Shaw
We hope you enjoy this episode of Don’t Eat Poop!
Connect with Francine, Matt, and the “Don’t Eat Poop!” show on LinkedIn!
Check out Francine’s book Who Watches the Kitchen? on Amazon!
🎙️ BE A GUEST ON DON’T EAT POOP!
Fill out this form to tell us more about yourself. We’ll reach out via email within 30 days with next steps if you’re selected.
